Maybe you start out determined to write a book and get it published. But if the rejections from agents pile up and the silence from publishers is unnerving – you might want to consider changing lanes and doing something else with your talent and your material. Something writerly.
Miss Piggy used to say, “If you can write a check, you can write a book.”
She'd have made a great book coach.
I come at it from another angle - if you can write a book, you can write a blog or a newsletter or an article or a podcast or a TED talk or whatever comes next. It doesn’t always have to be a book. Or it doesn't have to be a book right now.
I was reminded recently how important it is to get beyond the fantasy and the movie version of what it's like to get a book published. And to celebrate any and all of your achievements.
I don't mean to make light of what it takes to put a book aside. I know rejection can be crushing after you've put your heart and soul, imagination and intellect - not to mention years of your life - into a book that you realize may not get published.
I just mean - don't let that make you feel like you're not a writer. Like what you have to say isn't important just because an agent or twelve didn't fall in love with your story.
A good friend used to say that writing is such a tough business, you need to celebrate every accomplishment. Even if it's the courage to set the book aside for a while and do something else.
Sometimes I just start writing. I’ll hear a sentence in my mind and then . . .
And yes, sometimes I write in circles and never get to the point. Or I bury the lede. Or I do too much vamping or warming up. And very often I toss the whole thing.
And yes, I know, I should practice what I teach. Follow a blueprint. Make an outline. Maybe just a mind map.
But the truth is – I always have to start by writing.
When I ran workshops, I loved to use a snippet of eavesdropped conversation. And let the group go from there.
My favorite – once on a very bad date, I was hiding out in the ladies’ room when two very tall, very thin, young women came in to comb their very straight blond hair. Swedish most likely. Leather pants. One said to the other – “I’ve got to talk to Hans alone tonight.”
Then what? I said to the workshop.
One writer came back immediately. The other woman said, “Anything you want to say to Hans, you can say in front of me.”
And he took the story in a whole new direction. Pantsing.
In a class called Living Writers, the teacher asked me – What was the song you heard while you were writing your novel? How did he know I kept hearing the rhythm of Simon and Garfunkel’s “We’ve all come to look for America”? Pantsing set to music.
I love to show writers Jennie Nash’s Blueprint for a Novel. It’s brilliant and helpful and just what a writer needs to get started or to fix a novel that’s gone sideways.
I especially like the early questions. Why are you writing this book? Who are you writing for? And what’s the point?
Too often I find myself 20 or 30 or even 50 pages into a manuscript and I still have no idea what the story is about. That’s not good.
With Jennie’s Blueprint the writer would have sorted all that out before writing the book. Saved time, cut down on frustration.
Right now I’m learning how to use the Story Arc structure for Fictionary. Five points -the inciting incident, the first plot point, the middle, the second plot point, the climax. Brilliant as well. With the help of AI writers can make sure they don’t wait too long to start or rush in too soon to wrap things up.
You need a finished draft. But like the Blueprint, it may save you from writing 5 or 6 or 7 more drafts when all you need are three.
As I’m thinking through this next novel – I’ll start with the title. And probably won’t do anything until I’ve got that first sentence. And I hear the characters talking. And I can see where they live.
I probably won’t know what it’s about or who it’s for. I probably won’t know the first plot point or where I’ll put the climax.
After I flounder for a while, I’ll probably take out the Blueprint and give it a shot. Finish a draft and try the story arc. But I’ll do an awful lot of pantsing first. Because that’s just how some of us write.
I always wanted to be a writer. But I was sure everyone else wanted that too. How could they not? Wasn’t telling stories what life was all about? I was five.
My first real assignment was a column in the camp newspaper. Sleep-away camp. All girls. They enjoyed my letters home so much; they reprinted them – complete with crude drawings about camp activities and the occasional melodramatic – if you really loved me, you’d take me home.
This was followed by my minor success as a playwright. I wrote and staged a play in my backyard, invited the neighbors and raised $12.00 for Jerry’s Kids. I was six.
The years between first and third grade are murky. Too much time practicing piano (badly), ballet dancing (badly), tap dancing (not so bad), and dodgeball (very badly). But then in third grade I wrote the all third-grade play, directed it, starred in it and got my picture in the local newspaper.
Success came more slowly after that. Yes, the cover of the 6th grade yearbook featured my poem. The teacher read my essays in English class in 7th grade; my 10th grade teacher said one of my papers was “worthy of publication”; and in my one creative writing class in college, my teacher devoted a whole class to my stories. And then I stopped.
A teacher in my MFA program once said – “It takes 10 years to live down your promise.” I confess I took a lot longer.
I'd always been a very good reader. I often read more than a book a week. Even though I never really loved Little Women or Jane Eyre or that whole Cherry Ames series – I read widely.
Which I was sure meant the minute I finally got up the courage to write, I’d be able to write a novel. I knew, in the deepest part of me I’d absorbed all these books, so even if I didn’t know it consciously, subconsciously my brain was primed for novel writing.
Only it wasn’t. I didn’t have a clue. Everything I wrote was too cute or too boring or too short. Now what?
I’ve since learned we introverts have our own way of tackling problems, mostly by doing things on our own. So every morning I sat down to write ‘a novel’ (ironic quotes). Then I’d read a book about craft. There weren’t nearly as many books then as there are now, so it was easy to do a whole library shelf of craft books. Then I’d read about psychology. I was the first to admit I was sheltered, naïve, and unable to look too critically at people. I spent the rest of the day with my family.
Somehow with this clumsy routine I wrote a novel. (In pre-computer days this meant renting time at an office with a Word Processor – if you’re old enough to remember Wang. Spending hours correcting and printing. ) I had it professionally printed and took it over to whatever FedEx was at the time. I’d spent more than $100.00 on computer time, printing, postage. But I knew it had to get out right away.
The agent returned it two days later. Less than one dollar in postage. He was going to pass – I needed an agent who was hungrier.
These days the line is – I didn’t fall in love.
One agent and one former editor were kind enough to read the book. None of their comments were good. I told the editor I tended to over write. She said – Faulkner overwrites. You write sloppy. And the agent said the book would never sell.
Brenda Ueland in her book If You Want to Write – gives two excellent pieces of advice. Avoid boring people. And the best way to fix one story is to write the next.
We held a wake and farewell for the sweet first novel, and I wrote the next. More books on craft. More novels for inspiration.
I gathered my courage and attended a summer writer’s workshop. The teacher said I had very good verbs, but the problem was my structure.
Structure? I had no idea what that was.
I’d gone as far as I could on my own. So I applied to MFA programs.
A year later, I asked if we were going to study structure. The teacher scoffed. That’s not what we’re here for, he said. If you want to learn about structure, pick up a book at the drugstore.
Believe it or not, this was a time when my local drugstore actually carried a book called something like How to Structure Your Novel. (Don’t try looking for it at CVS today.)
Thanks to the teachers in the MFA program and my terrific classmates, I wrote a novel. Got a super-agent and had it published by a respectable NY publisher. My lovely editor even indulged me by meeting at the Algonquin for lunch. Earned a few reviews, not much money, but I had the book party I’d always dreamt of, only it turned out to be way too stressful.
The secret no one tells you is that after dreaming all these years of getting published, even though it’s exciting - it can also be a big letdown in a lot of ways. Half the writers I knew either went into therapy or went on Prozac. Or both.
Stuck on what to write for the second novel, I thought – why not take everything I’ve learned and use it to spare other writers from going through the long, tedious, learning process that had taken me years?
And that’s how I got here – Book Coaching. First teaching – University adjunct track – Freshman Comp; then adult fiction workshops; then college workshops; then individual sessions with writers. A few detours to do what used to be called book doctoring; some professional proofreading; and of lot of editing.
When I found out I could use it all, every messy bit of it, for book coaching, I’ve been smiling ever since. I feel like I’ve found my niche.
One more thing: While I was waiting to find my real calling, I learned about indie publishing and started what’s probably called a micro-press. But I’ll tackle that story somewhere else. If you’d like to work with me – I promise I’ll share my years of accumulated wisdom.
Back in the very dark ages when it seemed like I was job hunting every other year, there were a few interview questions that always had me stumped.
Yup. That one about Tell us your faults or Give an example of one of your mistakes. In other words, Please take a few moments to humiliate yourself.
But the one that always got to me was - Why should I hire you instead of xxx? What makes you any better than xxx?
Just to illustrate a mistake I often make – I answered honestly.
I said Washington was full of terrific writers. They could just as easily hire any one of them. I wasn’t at all sure I was any better but I have a pretty good sense of humor. And I almost always meet deadlines.
I know. Pretty lame. It’s a wonder I got any jobs.
I was reminded of that ordeal this afternoon when – as part of an exercise for a course I’m taking – I looked at about a dozen websites for other book coaches.
Not only do they have websites that move and dance and pop up with chances to subscribe to newsletters or schedule phone calls – so many of them are award-winning, industry-savvy book coaches with wonderful head shots, and – no guarantees of course – they’ve coached dozens of writers onto the best seller lists.
I’m pretty sure they’re all very good. They can fill up pages and charts and lists of what they can do for an author. Something I can’t do. It’s so much easier to just say – I can help you write your book.
So I’m back to that tiresome question. Why should you hire me to help you write your book? The answer is still the same – I’ve got a pretty good sense of humor. And I almost always meet deadlines.
I loved fairy tales. I knew what I’d do if offered three wishes. I was sure I’d be nice to the king’s youngest son – even in disguise.
I wanted to be a writer because you could tell stories all day. Live in a house by the beach. Never work in an office.
Best of all – you’d have an editor who understood exactly what you wanted to say and fixed everything you wrote and made it better.
But. Becoming a writer means not only learning how to accept criticism, it also means killing your darlings, and letting go of the fantasies.
No matter how many novels or stories I wrote or tried to write, no matter how many jobs I had working as a writer, the magical editor never appeared. I’d always be faced with marked-up copy that left me with days of revising. So when someone sends me a manuscript that’s a bit of a mess and I know they’re hoping I’ll send it back all polished and perfect. I try to break it to them gently.
Maybe 20 years ago, although it could have been 30, I was friendly with a writer who was working on a novel. In December she told me if she didn’t have it finished and sold by April, she would stop writing. She was approaching 40—she couldn’t afford to waste too much time if she didn’t have immediate success.
I’d been teaching novel writing for a few years and I knew that for most writers 6 months wasn’t nearly enough time to write a good book, find a good a agent, and sell it to a good publisher. So I asked her—if she got to April and she hadn’t accomplished everything, what would she do? She said she’d just stop. End of story. She’d do something else.
I could have told her, and maybe I did—it doesn’t work like that. Writers write. That’s what they do and if they don’t meet some arbitrary deadline they’ve set for themselves based on who knows what formula—they keep writing.
Not her, she said. So sure she’d be finished with the novel and happy with her new agent.
Here’s what happened. April came, the novel wasn’t done. It wasn’t even finished by the following April—and to no one’s surprise she was still writing. It took four years for her to finish the book. She did get an agent. No publishers picked it up. So she started the next book.
Ten years later she was still writing.
I’ve lost count of how many writers I’ve worked with in the past 20 or 30 years who have told me they have an absolute deadline. Before the kids get out of school. Until I need to find a new job. (I won’t even mention that wild November ride with NanoWriMo that may have made this whole fake deadline syndrome worse.)
The pandemic has created even more of these false deadlines because sooner or later kids will return to school and offices will reopen and all that free time will shrink. Right now I know at least three writers who have to be done by June, July, and August. Otherwise . . .
Here’s a secret I sometimes try to share. The deadlines are meaningless. Unless they’ve got a contract, an advance, and a drop-dead submission date from a publisher, the deadlines they’ve set for themselves don’t carry much weight.
Writers write. Books take as long as they take. Agents aren’t always easy to get and even then, there’s no guarantee a publisher will buy the book.
So instead of driving yourself crazy to meet some arbitrary deadline—let your imagination set the schedule; give the book as much time and space as it needs.
Enjoy the process.
No matter what date you’ve set for yourself, if you want to write a book, you’ll keep on writing.
It used to be when you were just starting out to write a novel, common wisdom had it you'd need to do at least 5 drafts - 5 complete drafts, not just fiddling and tweaking - before you could even consider your manuscript ready for anyone else to read.
It's worth repeating. At least 5 drafts.
Five times you'd start at the beginning and go all the way through and do more than just move the words around - you'd come up with new situations, kill off a few characters, and how did a horse get in there? You'd go from first person to third and then back again only to wake up in the middle of the night and realize you needed both but from two very different point of view characters.
By the time you got to the third draft, everything had changed. And it wasn't until the fourth draft that you realized what you were writing about. But the really important twist didn't surface until the fifth.
Even after that, there would be more drafts because an agent asked you and more again because your editor had a few ideas.
In other words, it took a long time to put together a good novel.
Note: This isn't about questioning whether you can write a novel in a month. Like this month. Although I may be one of the few who think you can't.
When I taught classes and workshops I'd mix metaphors shamelessly. The first draft, I'd say, is making the clay, the next several are shaping it.
Or else I'd say, I imagined it was like writing a symphony (as if I'd have a clue how that's done). In my imagination you'd need one draft for the strings, another for the horns, someway to put them all together and see if they could produce music. Only to come back and start again because you'd left out a part for the oboe.
No matter how I tried to describe, it I knew from my own experience and from working with other writers, it's almost impossible to nail it the first time through.
And then there's the idea that you might need to write one or twelve novels before you got it right and had something publishable. But that's for another post.
The reason I mention this about drafts, here on my coaching website, is because I often have the feeling that when writers start to work with me, they're under the impression it's kind of one and done.
They do a draft while I read over their shoulder and make pointed comments and hope that once they make the changes I've suggested, they've got a manuscript that's good to go.
The hard, bitter, crushing truth is that's hardly ever true. In fact, never. It's just too hard to handle so many moving parts the first time through.
Yes, working with a coach can save you from wasting time floundering. And having an outline can keep you from getting lost. Spending weeks thinking it all through ahead of time before you write that first chapter, can save you weeks of spinning your wheels. But. Can you really get it right on the first draft?
Look, the whole idea of creative writing is to keep your mind open to possibilities. So yes, it's possible you could get it all right in one draft. But when I work with someone I can only promise I'll get them through a draft or two. I never promise that when this draft is finished, whether it's the first or third, that you'll have a polished manuscript.
Writers often interview me before they decide if we should work together. They want to know about fees and deadlines. But we never discuss if they're secretly hoping when we get done with a draft, they can send it out
So, if you're reading this because you're thinking of contact me - I hope you'll take to heart this bit of common wisdom. I do believe it takes at least 3-5 drafts to finish a manuscript. But I do try to make all that work interesting.